Perbandingan / Keuntungan / Kelebihan LED dibandingkan dengan HID (HPS/Metal Halide)
|
Comparison/Benefit/Advantage of LED vs HID |
||
| HID | LED | |
| Transformer (Trafo) | Ballast | Driver |
|
Ecologically Friendly(Ramah Lingkungan) |
Not so much (Kurang) | Yes , No Toxic Chemical and Recycleable (Non-kimia dan dapat didaur ulang) |
| Energy Efficiency (Efisiensi Energi) | No | 30 – 50% compare to HID |
| Durability (Ketahanan) | Fragile – has moving parts, glass bulbs, and filaments (Banyak komponen dan filamen/bohlam) | Heavy-duty – has no electrode or filament, shock & vibration resistant (Durable) (Kuat Tahan Lama, Tahan benturan dan getaran) |
| Maintenance Cost (Biaya Pemeliharaan) | High (Tinggi) | Low (No maintenance needed/ No Bulb Replacement) (Tidak perlu pemeliharaan dan jarang mengganti Bohlam) |
| Lifetime (Umur) | 15,000 to 25,000 hours | 60,000 – 100,000 hours |
| Lumen Depreciation (Penurunan Lumen) | Moderately high (Tinggi) | Low (Rendah) |
| Cold Tolerant (Toleransi Suhu Dingin) | – 40 F | -30 F (instant on) Extremely Hot and Cold Condition |
| Light Dispersement(Distribusi Cahaya) | Moderate (Sedang) | Better,with good illumination design (Lebih Bagus) |
| Performance (Kinerja) | Requires 5-10 minute warm-up time (Perlu 5-10 menit) | Turns on instantly, no flickering, creates focused light (LANGSUNG) |
| Frequent On-off Switching ( Switch berulang-ulang) | Not Allowed (Tidak Boleh) | OK |
| Color Temperatures (Warna Temperatur) | Few Options (3000 to 5000 Kelvin) | Multiple Options (2700 to 6500 Kelvin) |
| Color Rendering | 5 to 93 CRI | Average 80 to 85 CRI |
| Dimmable?(Dapat meredup) | No (Tidak) | Most (Boleh) |
| Warranty (Garansi | Usually 1 years (1 Tahun) | 1-2 years (1 – 2 Tahun) |
| Cost (Biaya) | Lower upfront cost, but requires regular relamping and ballast replacement (Murah didepan, mahal dikemudian hari) | High upfront cost but virtually no maintenance expenses (Mahal didepan, murah di kemudian hari) |